Certification Behavior: Reviewer vs TTA
- Note, to Certify Conflicts, there can be no Conflict States of Unknown
- Use case 1:
- Automatic conflicts are determined. Then, a SRP member declares their conflicts, Certifies conflicts, and then cannot interact with conflict certification again.
- After the fact, they realize they need to change a Conflict State (either to available or to conflict). They contact (externally) the TTA Member.
- Use case 2:
- Automatic conflicts are determined. Then, a SRP member views their conflicts and disagrees with an autoConflict. They do not certify and instead notify the TTA member that the autoConflict should be changed.
- Option 1:
- We add a save button that allows the TTA member to update but not certify, as there will be Conflict States of Unknown. This button could work for Use Case 1 as well.
- Mark F. has concerns about edge cases in the UI.
- Option 2:
- The TTA member tells the SRP Member to declare their conflicts and certify.
- TTA Member goes into the Conflict Declaration UI and changes one (or more) Conflicts states as needed. TTA Member hits Certify, which is successful.
- Proposed Consequences:
- ISRs either become available or unavailable as necessary for the SRP Member.
- ISRs that are now Conflict State of Conflict that had Review Types other than None should automatically have Review Types changed to None.
- Implementation Details:
- A TTA member can certify as many times as necessary. Certify is a bulk action.
- A SRP Member only can see the Conflict Declaration UI if they are Uncertified. TTA members can always see the Conflict Declaration UI.
- Conflict State transitions are Role specific:
- Valid Conflict State transitions for a TTA Member:
- Available → Available
- Available → Conflict
- Conflict → Available
- Conflict → Conflict
- AutoConflict → Available
- Valid Conflict State transitions for SRP Member:
- Unknown → Available
- Unknown → Conflict
- Concerns:
- What happens if the Review States are Finalized?
- What happens if an external ISR is added after the main panel's ISRs are Finalized?
- Should the system prevent changes to Conflict State based on Review State?
