...
- TAC comments for the PI
- filled out by TTA members before, during, and after TAC meeting
- to be reviewed the TAC chair
- Internal comments
- filled out by TTA members before and during TAC meeting
- will capture scheduler's comments for the TAC as they determine preliminary scheduling priorities prior to TAC
- will capture notes during the TAC meeting that may inform the TAC comments for the SRP
- assume various TTA members will communicate with each other as they edit the comments
- Note, this is not the same comments as the Internal Comments from the SRP, which belong to the Proposal Review entitydsb: In the System Description we have Comments for the PI and Internal CommmentsComments, similar to the review comments. Here the Internal Comments were comments from the TAC to NRAO. What I thought we agreed to was to add any comments from the TTA Group (e.g., comments from the scheduler 's comments to the TAC). That is, combine different internal comments into one field.
We agreed that Scheduling Priorities should be assigned to a Observation Specification Disposition and NOT the Allocation Disposition.
...
| Expand |
|---|
| title | TAC member responsibilities |
|---|
|
As a TAC member I want to review Proposals so I can make recommendations for the Director’s Review. |
|
|
|
|
|
| As a TAC member I want to have visibility without restriction to all Proposals just as I did in SRPs so I can review their details if needed. But this is not the same as during the SRP meeting. During the SRP meeting the SRP chair could not see proposals for which they were conflicted.
As a TAC member I want to have visibility without restriction to all Proposals so I can review their details as needed. |
| As a TAC member I want to modify the Comments to the PI and the TAC comments for the PI for proposals that belong to my panel. I do not think we want the TAC member to be able to modify the SRP comments at this stage.
| As a TAC member I want access to the Facility Reports so I can understand what can be scheduled. | As a TAC member I want access to the Proposal Summary so I understand what the requested resources are. |
| As a TAC member I want to see the Proposal information which includes Allocation Requests, Author, Co-Is, Abstract, Title, Scientific Justification, Technical Justification so I understand resources of the PI and their request. | As a TAC member I want to filter on proposals so I can efficiently navigate the proposals for the TAC meeting. | As a TAC member I would like there to be a way in the UI to keep track of what Proposals we have come to a consensus on. | As a TAC member I want printable views of the Facility Reports so I don’t have to look at the computer during the TAC meeting. | As a TAC member I want printable views of the Proposal Summary so I don’t have to look at the computer during the TAC meeting. |
| As a TAC member I want to see the SRP Comments, Feasibility Comments, Scientific Merit Metric, and the TTA member’s comments for all the proposals. | As a TAC member I want printable view for one or all of the proposals so I do not have to look at the computer during the TAC meeting. | As a TAC member I would like one of the filter or sort options to be if we have come to consensus on a proposal. |
| As a TAC member I would like the Proposal Summary to compare the time/resources of the Allocation Request vs the Allocation Disposition. |
| As a TAC member I want to see the Allocation Dispositions so I can understand what the TTA member suggests as a Scheduling Priority. | As a TAC member I would like to filter on what proposals are included in the print out because we don’t always discuss the proposals by Proposal ID order or facility agnostic. |
|
| As a TAC member I want to know which proposals are Joint Proposals (external and internal) even if I am just reviewing ADs from a single Facility so I can holistically understand the request. |
| As a TAC member I want to some key pieces of information readily accessible to me so I can navigate the proposals in a summary mode and not be overwhelmed by the Proposal details unless I want them. | As a TAC member I want to know if I am conflicted on a Proposal. |
|
|
|
|
...
| Expand |
|---|
| title | TAC Chair Responsibilities |
|---|
|
| As TAC Chair I would like have boarder access to the Proposals than the normal TAC members. |
|
|
|
|
| As a TAC chair I want to modify some information about a proposal or AD. | As a TAC Chair I want to be able to modify the binary metric on External Facilities so I can indicate that they are recommended to be approved or not by the TAC. | As a TAC Chair I want to mark if I have completed my review of the Proposals and the TAC comments to the PI so I can sign off on the TAC recommendations. | As a TAC Chair I want to know who is conflicted on a Proposal even though the TAC member can still see its contents. |
| As a TAC chair I want to modify TAC comments to PI and internal comments for the TAC until Disposition Letters are sent. |
|
| As a TAC Chair I want to know which Panel a Proposal is on. |
| As a TAC chair I want to modify SRP comments to PI. I do not think we want the TAC chair to be able to modify the SRP comments at this stage.
|
|
|
|
|
As a TTA member, I have many hats in during the TAC meeting. I may be taking notes in the Internal Comments or editing TAC comments for PI or even editing SRP Comments for PI. I could also be editing Observation Specification Dispositions on the fly, so I need access to all of the tools I had prior when I was building the ATM and OSDs. I'll likely just use versioning to make my edits, as I expect the information in the facility reports to be static once finalized for the TAC. However, I know I'm going to be preparing more reports for the Director's Review, based on the recommendations of the TAC.
...
