Page History

• SRP Reviewer
  
  • See list of proposals (after conflict certification)
  • Review Type is displayed
    • Default is None; otherwise P,S,T
  • Review State is displayed
    • default is Blank; otherwise Saved, Completed, Finalized, Closed
  • Conflict State is displayed
    • Conflict/Available
  • If not Conflicted, have an ISR in which to enter comments and a score and see the proposal
    • can Save (Review State → Saved) per ISR
      • validate if score not equal to 0; otherwise it cannot save
      • does not validate comments
    • can Complete (Review State → Completed) per ISR
    • can Finalize (bulk action) if any ISRs with Review not equal to None are not Closed or Finalized
  • If Conflicted, only see title, abstract, proposal ID and cannot enter any information
• All comments and scores are saved (though not propagated to consensus; see later)
• Normalized Individual Scores are calculated on Finalize
• Edge cases to test:
  • If an external proposal is added after reviewer has finalized, they should be able to review and finalize that one proposal (finalize is still bulk in theory)
  • If consensus has started for their panel, the Finalized Normalized Individual Score in that panel may be inconsistent with their new Noramlized Individual Score (since it has the extra proposal). This is acceptable.

• Conflict state not preventing visibility to proposals when appropriate

TTA Member

• can change Review State to Closed
  • Auto changes Review Type to None
• If a TTA member Finalizes a SRP member's ISRs (for the reviewer), it will finalize the ISRs that have a valid comment and score (Review State of Saved, Completed) and Review Type not equal to None. If a comment+score is not valid, regardless of the Review Type, it will Close the ISR (unsure if it still ignores review types of None)

SRP Member

• As a conflicted SRP member, only see the SRP scope, proposal ID, title, abstract
• As a non-conflicted SRP member, I want to see the comments, scores, and proposals for which I am not conflicted
  • Comments are not connected to reviewers
  • Normalized Individual Score
  • Finalized Normalized Individual Score
  • Mean Normalized Score
  • Standard Deviation of the Mean Normalized Score
  • SRP Score
• As a non-conflicted SRP member and with a Review Type of Primary or Secondary, I want to enter consensus comments.
• All members that are not conflicted can view Consensus comments
• Be able to see the updated SRP score, if it is changed by the chair or via changes to the Finalized Normalized Individual Score. Push or refresh.
• See Feasibility Reviews (on hold)
• As a Primary or Secondary, I want to complete a consensus comment
  • Members can no longer edit, but chair can
• Import/Export Consensus Comments

SRP Chair

• Overview of consensus comment state (Completed, Saved)
• Overview of Review Types and Conflict State
• Ability to change SRP Score directly
• Update Finalized Normalized Individual Scores
  • Forces update to MNS, STD_MNS, and SRP if the SRP score was not manually changed already
• Have visibility to past disposition letters
• Review Consensus comments, modify comments, and finalize Consensus Reviews
• History of Changes of Consensus Reviews to be kept

TTA Member

• Initiate Consensus per panel if all ISRs are Finalized
• Generate Normalized Linear Rank when all consensus reviews are finalized per panel.